next up previous
Next: Experiments on the speed Up: Relativistic Mechanics [8 lectures] Previous: The Galilean Transformation

The failure of the Galilean Transformation

Maxwell's equations, which summarise electricity and magnetism, cause the Galilean Transformation to fail on two counts ....
  1. They predict the speed of light is independent of the inertial reference frames instead of ($c'=c+v$) as required by Galilean Relativity.
  2. They are not invariant under the Galilean Transformation. (This is stated without proof in this course.)

More sophisticated experiments (specifically, experiments on the behaviour of light and experiments that dealt with fast moving particles) indicated that Galilean Relativity was approximately correct only for velocities much smaller than the speed of light.

What a conundrum !

Shall we throw out all the theories of Electro-magnetsim ? This is hard to do. If these theories seem to have no flaw in their derivation, are firmly based in

experiments, their predictions are verified by further experiments, and we all use our cell phones with impunity, then its hard to fault Maxwell's equations !

The problem must lie somewhere else ....

But where ?

Enter Special Relativity, which was first developed by Einstein (1905). This theory treats inertial reference frames in a way

that is compatible with all measurements so far. Later on, came General Relativity which is able to deal with non-inertial reference frames and also to provide a geometrical way of dealing with gravity.


next up previous
Next: Experiments on the speed Up: Relativistic Mechanics [8 lectures] Previous: The Galilean Transformation
Simon Connell 2006-02-21